Saturday Post: The Inevitable Rise Of Cockroach Media . . .
By Tom Foremski - February 7, 2009
CES in Las Vegas was made more tolerable because of the good company of fellow journalist blogger Paul Mooney. One late night we were discussing the media industry, an occasional favorite topic of mine.
We were discussing how the economic situation was going to accelerate the broad disruptive trend within the media industry.
Less advertising would lead to a faster rate of job losses, and lower revenues for most, if not all media companies, and that also includes many newer media companies, Gawker Media for example. Simply put, it's not a good time to be in media--mainstream or newstream.
More recently, the Wall Street Journal cut 25 newsroom jobs.
Here is part of a memo to staff from Robert Thomson, Managing Editor of the Wall Street Journal:
It is obvious to you all that we are in the midst of an unprecedented economic downturn. We are also in the midst of an unprecedented increase in our readership, in print and online, but a precipitous decline in print advertising revenue has forced a close examination of our structures and of our costs.
It points to a curious anomaly within news organizations, that readership is often rising but revenues are falling.
And the reason is that advertising is less expensive online but news creation costs remain the same. The cost of being in the news business isn't being covered by online advertising revenues.
Media companies such as Google and Yahoo can sell online advertising at low rates and cover their costs but Wall Street Journal and other news organizations cannot survive without shrinking their productive resources, which can create a downward spiral of less content, and less revenue.
When journalists lose their jobs it's tough because they also lose their publishing platform. They lose their byline, they disappear from public view, and that makes it more difficult finding a job. And even when better economic times return, the majority of journalism jobs won't ever return.
In Las Vegas, Paul Mooney and I were thinking that we are in a better position than many of our colleagues in the media because we don't have far to fall. As long as we can keep the lights on, and maintain an Internet connection, we can still keep publishing during bad times, and worsening times. If you lose your job at a news organization you lose your public persona--a journalist that isn't publishing isn't.
We joked that we represent a new type of media: cockroach media. Paul is from New York where cockroaches can be formidable in their ability to survive the harshest environments. He says, "I've given cockroaches some of my best hits and they still manage to crawl away."
Cockroach media will survive this economic downturn a lot better than old and new media companies. And cockroach media should do well once the inevitable upturn comes around.
- - -
Cockroach media:
Paul Mooney Living, Linking and Learning
« Guest Post: Bay Area PR Firms Help Non-Profits | Main | Hippies And Geeks Drop-In For Tim Leary Archive Project »
Posted to A Top Story | MediaWatch | Saturday Post
February 7, 2009 | Permalink | Comment | Subscribe to SVW
- Top Stories:
- Silicon Valley Goes To Paris... Le Web '09
- Turkey's Search Engine And The Backlash Against The Internet's 'Wal-Marts'
- A Saturday Post: Media In Crisis: I'm Thankful For Being Here Right Now...
- Guest Post: Social Media Marketing is Swiss Cheese
- A Single Search Index Would Speed Up The Entire Internet - A Zero Carbon Speed Boost
- The Dark Matter Of Internet Commerce - A Towering Pile of Scams - $1.4Bn And Counting...
- Groovy: Real-Time Data Could Aid Media Companies
- Tech Awards For Humanity: "Cash Prizes" Galore And Al Gore's Meaningless Speech . . . And Amazing Laureates!
- The Death Of The Search Algorithm? Techmeme Has Six Editors
- TEDxSF - Little TED Just Like The Big TED
- What's Next? Beyond Real-Time...
- PearlTrees: A Novel Approach To Human Mapping Of The Internet
Comments (5)
It's true that "cockroach media" may well weather the storm better than traditional journalists. But today's media landscape is inherently malleable. These laid-off, "old-school" journalists won't just sit on their hands and disappear, nor will they end up flipping burgers at McDonald's. Many will attempt to reinvent themselves and morph into "cockroaches". Just the way many former tech industry reporters and pundits are now successful bloggers, some of these journalists will create unique, compelling and successful blogs on a range of topics.
New media's barriers to entry are fairly low, and the marketplace of ideas is nearly infinite. But the number of readers -- and the amount of time they can spend bouncing between various news/info sites -- is finite. Increased volumes of "cockroach media" will mean fewer readers, less click-through, and reduced ad dollars for all.
It's the timeless problem with cockroaches... They multiply.
Posted: February 8, 2009 7:28 PM
Paul Davies: Yes, barriers to entry are low, but barriers to audience are high. Some will make the transition, Harry McCracken over at Technoligizer is one, and a good one. For most journalists, if they leave their job they lose their platform. And most journalists don't like to "blog" because it is a lot of work.
Posted: February 8, 2009 10:09 PM
In the interests of transparency my lights did get turned off twice! One time I was speaking on a panel so I brought my laptop to charge up while I was speaking. On another occasion I ran a long extension cord into the hallway of my apartment where the cleaners plug in their vacuums. My apartment manager wasn't pleased but...
Posted: February 9, 2009 3:40 PM
Granted, cockroaches are said to survive under nuclear reactors, but they are what they are. There just isn't much glory in having an exo-skeleton, even if you've out-survived everything else.
And I think that that low quality of personal brand is reflected in the minds of any given reader. Sure, we're in the public eye constantly, and our byline never goes away, but we're still just cockroach-bloggers. To a certain extent, anyone can have a blog, anyone can be a cockroach...
Posted: February 27, 2009 11:59 AM
CT Moore: Exoskeletons are tres cool! Yes, anyone can blog, the barrier is audience. But, you can still be a cockroach blogger AND have a large audience.
The point is that media companies, both traditional and new, have to have lots of capital to keep publishing, cockroach media just needs to be able to afford a cup of coffee in a wi-fi enabled cafe to keep publishing.
Posted: February 27, 2009 2:50 PM