11.20.06: ValleyWag speculates wildly on Benioff visit to WSJ

By Richard Koman - November 20, 2006

By Richard Koman for

Nick Denton has been furiously following up on his Friday scoop that Salesforce.com's Marc Benioff had Wall Street Journal reporter Pui-Wing Tam (one of the several reporters tailed by HP) arrested when she tried to get close to the five-acre estate he's building on the Big Island.

Denton says that Benioff also flew to New York with a money-looking fellow Journal reporters assumed to be a lawyer, specifically to "brow-beat" top brass about the reporter's activities. Denton offers no details of that meeting but plenty of speculation that the meeting was responsible for the fact that the Tam's story makes no mention of the incident. To be clear, Denton is accusing the Journal of squashing that part of the story out of some sort of gentlemen's agreement with Benioff.

That the accusation is the wildest of speculation based on the thinest of evidence is apparent from Denton's own words:

It's not clear whether Benioff's visit to the Journal's headquarters came before publication, [if] he [was] trying to head off publication, or at least mention of the incident; or, less likely, that the visit came after publication, and an effort to head off further such intrusive coverage. ...

The Journal, and [managing editor Paul] Steiger in particular, deal with aggrieved CEOs on a regular basis. The usual tactic is to be mollifying, without making any firm commitments. These discussions are generally off-the-record, so the paper would not normally feel able to disclose the fact of the conversation, or the content of Benioff's complaint. The paper, also, tries to keep its reporter's personalities, and their subjective personal experiences, out of the way of the story. However, the arrest of a reporter would be unusual enough normally to pierce even the Journal's usual discretion. ...

I suppose Valleywag is still looking to hire that seasoned reporter with strong journalistic instincts....




Share this article

 Subscribe in a reader

By Richard Koman - November 20, 2006 | Permalink | Comment | Category: News Watch
| SVW Toolbar | SVW Newsletter | SVW Mobile

Comments (3)

Danny:

"I suppose Valleywag is still looking to hire that seasoned reporter with strong journalistic instincts.... "

Are you being sarcastic? It's honestly hard to tell.


Tom Foremski [TypeKey Profile Page]:

No, Richard wasn't being sarcastic, I know it is sometimes difficult to tell but those are Nick Denton's words.
I suppose he's looking to create a type of Silicon Valley Watcher ;-)


I am suggesting that such is not yet in place at the "new" Valleywag, based on Denton's use of wild speculation in the face of facts to the contrary.

Those are Nick's words, the rationale for firing Douglas. Although note Mike Arrington's note a few days ago that Denton's rep for not being able to handle having writers that get more buzz than he does may be more to the point. The email to staff about the firing of Douglas focuses on his being told to 'lay off the press interviews.' It never really made sense that Douglas' blather about hoping to get sued was the problem. It makes more sense that the sin was collecting the press attention.


Post a comment