Bloggers could become easy prey to standard public relations techniques
By Tom Foremski - November 29, 2004
As companies and their public relations organizations ponder how to react to the “blogging” phenomenon, I’d like to point out some tricks of the trade used in the business of influencing media.
Forewarned is forearmed some say, and maybe some of the following will help bloggers who are not professional journalists.
I believe that some bloggers are in danger of losing their independence and their unique voice within the media landscape—if they become pulled into a sphere of influence. This is the “sphere” that professional journalists operate in every day and cannot avoid.
This sphere of influence has many aspects. It involves conversations with company representatives, being included in pre-briefings on important company announcements or mergers, prompt return of phone calls during breaking stories, invitations to events, being fed exclusive stories, and easy access to top executives. In each of those examples, there is a point of leverage that can be subtle, or it can be blunt and to the point.
I might not make too many friends by raising such topics but part of my mission with this venture is to educate readers about how the media “sausage” is made. And if bloggers give up a key vantage point as commentators on the media, by allowing themselves to be pulled into the sphere of influence, we will be poorer for it.
It is impossible to work as a professional journalist and not be influenced in some way. If this wasn’t true, there would not be a massive public relations industry. Many PR companies compare the cost of influencing editorial coverage with the cost of advertising in that publication. A common metric is a number that represents the ratio of: (PR cost of generating a certain amount of column inches in publication)/ advertising cost in that publication. Obviously, there is a higher value on editorial content.
More on this to follow…
[This is one of our “foundation” topics and there will be many more articles on this and related subjects. The goal is to foster a better approach to communicating ideas and generating high quality trusted media.]
By Tom Foremski - November 29, 2004 | Permalink
| Category: Media Watch
| SVW Toolbar | SVW Newsletter | SVW Mobile
- NEW STORIES:
- Top Blogger Pay Controversy - Pat Phelan
- FishWrap: The First Rule of PR . . . Kevin Maney's Briefs . . . Fortune's Brainstorm
- Friday News Watch: Intel Turns 40 . . .
- GOOG Continues to Out Compete its Partner Sites
- Lunch with Applied Materials: Looking to the Sun for New Business
- Sam Whitmore at Night: Media Struggling with Media Formats . . . and Leaving the Blogging Life
- Thursday Afternoon News Watch: AMD CEO Resigns, GOOG Dissapoints, MSFT's Big Expenses, IBM Beats Forecasts
- Thursday News Watch: Most Online Communities Fail . . .
- Anderson Defends Investing in the Long Tail
- Tuesday News Watch: YHOO, MSFT and Icahn Continue Spatting . . . [Don't they have any businesses to run?]
Comments
James on PRWatch: PR Firms That Don't Blog Yet Offer New/Social Media Practices
this is a great idea for PRwatch. I have been blogging also and I love your blog. mine is NFL Power Rankings
Dan on Searching for search on the iPhone - where is it?
I agree with the above limitations and may have another one...when I type a word and make a spelling mistake (big fingers) I can't seem to place the cursor in the middle of the word and correct the mistake. I have to place the cursor at the end of the word and delete back to the mistake and type again. This seems to be a huge waste of time and is functionality that should be included in a 'touch screen' iPhone Thoughts? Am I missing something?
Tom Foremski on Fridays with Foremski Coming in September...
Thanks Anna :-)
Anna Atwell on Fridays with Foremski Coming in September...
Tom-
Another reason to look forward to Fridays!
Sally Falkow on PRWatch: PR Firms That Don't Blog Yet Offer New/Social Media Practices
Hi Tom
I agree that a PR agency needs to know the tools before they can use them for clients.
I started blogging back in 2003 and I'm still going. I do well with teaching others to blog.
In frustration I developed a small newsroom with rss feeds in 2004 because I could not find one at that time that did exaclty what I wanted. Now PRESSfeed is used by companies and other agencies.
I have been interested in podcasting but had not done it much myself, so conse
Gerd Leonhard on Public Relations is Such a Sensitive Profession . . .
Tom, good post. You may enjoy my slideshow on the Future of PR, here: http://www.mediafuturist.com/2008/03/presentation-on.html - would love to have your feedback, too.
Andrew Finlayson on Innovation Journalism At Stanford - And Japan's Interest in Silicon Valley As Media Valley
Hope you had a good trip to Japan. I wonder if you have seen the website www.livenewscameras.com
Do you know of any Japanese networks that are streaming live news coverage?
Tom Foremski on We Have a Serious Innovation Deficit Says Silicon Valley Thought Leader Judy Estrin
Don, are you talking about innovation across sectors are just in the telco/Ribbit niche?
Don Thorson on We Have a Serious Innovation Deficit Says Silicon Valley Thought Leader Judy Estrin
Ms Estrin is not seeing what I'm seeing. I'm seeing an innovation rebirth happening on a scale as big as any ever seen in Silicon Valley. It's true it may not look the same as the others - may not be as visible on the surface or share the same characteristics or metrics as the others - but in terms of rapid and significant global impact, this wave will out do them all. No question.
Innovation is still accelerating and I think we are again at an inflection point. Hold on, the brakes a
Ryan G on Craigslist is being blocked by Cox Interactive - is this a net neutrality issue?
Pardon the pun, but I don't think that Cox would have the balls.
Luca Penati on Public Relations is Such a Sensitive Profession . . .
PR is not synonymous with “publicist”
http://www.techprnibbles.com/pr-is-not-synonymous-with-publicist/
tom Foremski on "Social" Product Pitches Ring False . . .
JL: Yes, that is exactly why I didn't want to use "Social media release" because it was clear that "Social Media" like "Green" was part of a current fad/fashion and thus worth staying away from. That's why I wanted "New media release" or just "media release" because these are neutral terms - they don't snag on our social fabric.
Although I found no supporters for my position I was very calm and centered because I knew I would be vindicated ;-)
And it turns out sooner than late
JL on "Social" Product Pitches Ring False . . .
Blame the marketers. Since when did "social" and "business" mix? This sounds similar to all the things that are labeled "green" this and "green" that...
Tom on Warsaw University Team Are World Programming Champions, Again
I am disppointed with the British efforts, in this field, they can't compete with eastern european countries. Duirng the war years the UK was a poineer in technology and programming skills, now it is a poor problem solving contestant.
Tom Foremski on Google is a Media Company
Ron: The branding of Google is interesting because if it were recognized as a media company the media industry might get a clue about the mess it is in. Google is leading the commoditization of content trend. And it's interesting Google doesn't want to be seen as a media company because it wouldn't be good for business.
Ethan: Yes, you are right I can buy a search appliance box but that's less than 1 percent of its revenues. It doesn't make it a technology company...
Tom Foremski on 7 Reasons Startups Should Not Take VC Funding - Advice from a Serial Entrepreneur
Greg: Your advice is worth a lot of money to those that understand it.
Greg Gianforte on 7 Reasons Startups Should Not Take VC Funding - Advice from a Serial Entrepreneur
Tom: Thanks for re-posting my guest column. As you noted, this advice is just as relevant today as it ever was, especially in light of current economic conditions. Long live the Bootstrapper.
- Greg
Ethan Grago on Google is a Media Company
What can I buy from Google? An enterprise search appliance, if I was so minded.
Ron on Google is a Media Company
Unless you're into defining categories, the question of whether or not Google is a media or a technology company isn't really interesting. Companies grow into many different areas and therefore defy categorization (is MSFT an enterprise or consumer software company? For that matter, is GM a car company or a financing company and pension fund that also happens to sell some cars?)
But to answer your question directly, you can buy (license) Google search technology for your website or in
dan on 7 Reasons Startups Should Not Take VC Funding - Advice from a Serial Entrepreneur
but some of us need to make a living...