Loading Up On BS In Silicon Valley
By Tom Foremski - August 17, 2009
It's always interesting to meet with outsiders and to hear their view of Silicon Valley, just as it is to leave the valley and notice that there's a whole world outside of our echo chamber (that doesn't care about our little world and its spats and spittle.)
Last week I was on a panel with Carolyn Pritchard, from GigaOm, speaking about the future of journalism. As always, it's the people that turn up to such events that interest me the most.
One of the people I met was Jose A. Del Moral, A Spanish entrepreneur. He was visiting for a few weeks and popping into various events around Silicon Valley. He said he was shocked about how positive everyone is in Silicon Valley.
Mr Del Moral wrote a blog post: There is a lot of bullshit in Silicon Valley.
Everybody is so nice! You have to be really careful, as people are not so honest with how they really feel. There is a lot of bullshit in Silicon Valley! If you come here with white shoes, they will get brown so fast...
He wasn't that impressed with a workshop he attended: "PR Buzz for Early-Stage Startups"
...I admire Jeremiah Owyang for his sage blogging, and also enjoyed listening to PR consultant Jeremy Toeman and Clara Shih, who has just published a book about Facebook. But half of what they said was bullshit. "It's hard to come across as authentic if you promote a revolution that you personally stand to benefit the most from", as Scott Berkun pointed out a month ago.[Calling bullshit on social media]
Fair enough but who else would promote a revolution if they have nothing to gain from it?
When we met I said, yes, it's true, there sometimes doesn't seem to be much critical thought in SIlicon Valley, there are a lot of people promoting the positive aspects of technology and technology trends. However, I said that in Europe, the reverse seems true - there is more criticism, it is much easier to be cynical and negative than it is to be positive.
Clearly, blind positivism isn't the answer, it's something in-between. Personally, I think that you need to be careful where you step in Silicon Valley -- and visitors should never wear white shoes.
« TrendWatch: One Ring To Bind Them All - The Quest And The Folly | Main | Bad News For TV - Study Shows Internet Advertising More Effective Than TV For Packaged Goods »
August 17, 2009 | Permalink | Comment | Category: Silicon Valley | Subscribe to SVW
- Top Stories:
- Technology In The Service Of Humanity
- The Death Of The Search Algorithm? Techmeme Has Six Editors
- TEDxSF - Little TED Just Like The Big TED
- SNCR Research: Social Media IS Influencing Business Decisions
- What's Next? Beyond Real-Time...
- PearlTrees: A Novel Approach To Human Mapping Of The Internet
- MediaWatch Analysis Part II: Google Has More To Lose Than Murdoch
- MediaWatch Analysis: Murdoch Will Negotiate Payment For Access To Basket Of Content With GOOG et al
- WeekendWatcher: The Sheer Number Of Things Will Devalue Them
- ChipWatch - Where Will The Next Generation Of Engineers Come From?
- Public Healthcare Could Cut Startup Costs And Help Spur Innovation
- Is GOOG's $750m AdMob Buy Strategic Or Dumb? An alternate view...
Comments (2)
California has always been full of hype since the Gold Rush. As a former Dataquest analyst, we always divided the hype by half to get to the truth. Foreigners are so gullible since they often believe the streets are paved with gold. If they read history, they learned the successful 49ers made their fortunes selling food, tools, jeans and services, not from gold.
Posted: August 19, 2009 12:43 AM
Sheridan: In this case, it's the foreigners that are wondering why we, the ones that are here, are so gullible...
Posted: August 19, 2009 11:59 AM